Shreveport, LA, September 30, 2025
News Summary
Fertitta’s Delicatessen in Shreveport marks 96 years of family ownership, highlighting its famous ‘Muffy’ sandwich. Agatha Fertitta-McCall continues her family’s culinary tradition by maintaining its charm and adapting to modern flavors. The deli, recognized as a historic landmark, boasts a dedicated family-run staff, ensuring a homely atmosphere. Agatha plans a special event to commemorate her birthday and the anniversary, reinforcing the deli’s significance in the community and its commitment to future generations.
Shreveport – Fertitta’s Delicatessen is celebrating 96 years of family ownership and iconic culinary offerings with a focus on its signature muffuletta sandwich, affectionately known as the “Muffy.” Located at 1124 Fairfield Ave., the deli has become a cherished community landmark since it was established in 1927 by Agatha Fertitta-McCall’s grandparents, John and Mary Fulco. Today, Agatha continues to run the beloved eatery that her family has owned for nearly a century.
Agatha Fertitta-McCall has successfully managed the restaurant for 45 years, maintaining a steady flow of customers despite the competition from chain restaurants. Under her leadership, the business has preserved its traditional charm while adapting to modern culinary trends, including the addition of vegetarian options and salads to its menu.
The deli originally operated as a grocery store and was named after Christian Street before being renamed Sam R. Fertitta Drive in honor of Agatha’s father, Sam R. Fertitta. Recognized as one of the oldest continuously family-owned restaurants in Louisiana, its legacy is evidenced by its inclusion in the Historic Landmark Registry in 2000, highlighting its historical significance in the community.
Fertitta’s is famous for its “Muffy” sandwich, a distinctive variation of the traditional muffuletta, featuring American cold cuts, mozzarella, yellow mustard, and a proprietary olive mix. The deli’s original neon sign, which proclaims the establishment’s title as the “Home of the Muffy,” is a locally recognized emblem, albeit with the name shortened for financial reasons.
Fertitta’s staff comprises only family members, creating a homely atmosphere that resonates with both regulars and newcomers alike. Agatha is assisted by her husband, Robert, as well as family members like her sister-in-law, Mary Alice Fertitta. Even her children lend a hand at times, reinforcing the familial ambiance. Moreover, Agatha Fertitta-McCall actively connects with customers through storytelling, often sharing anecdotes about the deli’s rich history.
In a testament to its lasting appeal, Fertitta’s has become a popular tourist attraction for those in search of authentic culinary experiences. The deli’s walls are adorned with various photographs and memorabilia showcasing its longstanding history. Agatha Fertitta-McCall plans to mark her 75th birthday with a book signing event on October 5, coinciding with the deli’s 96th anniversary, further solidifying the familial commitment to the establishment.
The deli has also served as a venue for community gatherings, weddings, and family celebrations, solidifying its position as a staple of local culture. Despite the economic pressures faced over the years, including the decline of local neighborhoods and the rise of big box stores, Fertitta’s has retained its allure and continues to be a pivotal part of the Shreveport community. Agatha hopes to pass the rich tradition of the deli on to her twin grandsons in the future, ensuring that the family’s legacy continues for generations to come.
Key Highlights of Fertitta’s Delicatessen
- Founded in 1927 by John and Mary Fulco
- Operated by Agatha Fertitta-McCall for 45 years
- Known for the “Muffy” sandwich
- Added to the Historic Landmark Registry in 2000
- All employees are family members
FAQs
What is Fertitta’s Delicatessen known for?
Fertitta’s is known for its signature sandwich, the “Muffy,” which is a variation of the traditional muffuletta.
When was Fertitta’s Delicatessen established?
Fertitta’s Delicatessen has been in business since 1927.
Who currently owns Fertitta’s Delicatessen?
The eatery is owned by Agatha Fertitta-McCall, who has operated the restaurant for 45 years.
What was the original purpose of Fertitta’s?
The deli initially began as a grocery store opened by Agatha’s grandparents.
What notable recognition has Fertitta’s received?
In 2000, the building was added to the Historic Landmark Registry, enhancing its recognition as a community treasure.
Who helps run Fertitta’s Delicatessen?
All employees at Fertitta’s are family members, creating a homely atmosphere for customers.
Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic
HERE Resources
Additional Resources
- Shreveport Times: Oldest Restaurants Still Striving
- Shreveport Bossier Advocate: Sicilian Soul Food at Fertitta’s Deli
- Shreveport Times: Fertitta’s Deli Image
- Shreveport Times: Another Fertitta’s Image
- Legacy: John Greer Obituary
Author: STAFF HERE SHREVEPORT WRITER
The SHREVEPORT STAFF WRITER represents the experienced team at HEREShreveport.com, your go-to source for actionable local news and information in Shreveport, Caddo Parish, and beyond. Specializing in "news you can use," we cover essential topics like product reviews for personal and business needs, local business directories, politics, real estate trends, neighborhood insights, and state news affecting the area—with deep expertise drawn from years of dedicated reporting and strong community input, including local press releases and business updates. We deliver top reporting on high-value events such as Mudbug Madness Festival, Red River Revel Arts Festival, and Independence Bowl. Our coverage extends to key organizations like the Shreveport-Bossier Chamber of Commerce and Shreveport Regional Arts Council, plus leading businesses in gaming, healthcare, and energy that power the local economy such as Horseshoe Casino, Ochsner LSU Health, and Atmos Energy. As part of the broader HERE network, including HEREBatonRouge.com and HERENewOrleans.com, we provide comprehensive, credible insights into Louisiana's dynamic landscape.
